Send your details to us and we will call you back to take further information about your matter.
Send your details to us and we will call you back to take further information about your matter.
A Family Court judge was wrong to conclude that a mother had influenced her young son against his father without first properly considering her allegations of domestic abuse, the High Court has ruled.
Allowing the mother’s appeal, Mrs Justice Harris said the trial judge had adopted the wrong approach by focusing on alleged alienating behaviour before deciding whether the child’s reluctance to spend time with his father could instead have been an appropriate response to the mother’s claims of coercive and controlling behaviour.
The case concerned arrangements for a five-year-old boy following his parents’ separation. The Family Court had increased the amount of time the child spent with his father after finding there was a probability that the mother had influenced the child’s attitude towards him.
The High Court held that where domestic abuse is alleged, the court must first consider whether a child’s reluctance to spend time with a parent is an appropriate and justified response to that abuse, or the result of protective behaviour by the other parent. Only if that is not the case should the court go on to consider whether the parent has engaged in alienating behaviour.
Mrs Justice Harris also found that the mother had not been given a fair opportunity to answer the allegations made against her. The father had not formally sought findings of alienating behaviour, there was no schedule setting out such allegations and the mother had not been cross-examined about them before the findings were made. The High Court concluded that this amounted to procedural unfairness.
In reaching its decision, the High Court endorsed the approach set out in recent guidance from the Family Justice Council on responding to allegations of alienating behaviours. The guidance emphasises that allegations of domestic abuse and parental alienation should not be treated as equivalent and that domestic abuse issues should be resolved first where they are relevant to the child’s welfare.
The High Court also criticised the failure to consider special measures for the mother during the remote hearing. Despite her allegations of domestic abuse, there was no evidence that the court had considered whether participation directions were needed to help her give her best evidence, as required by the Family Procedure Rules and the Domestic Abuse Act 2021.
The appeal was allowed and the case has been sent back to the Family Court to be heard again by a different judge.
Please contact us if you would like more information about the issues raised in this article or any aspect of family law.
Case details
XZ v YZ [2026] EWHC 1521 (Fam)
High Court, Family Division
Mrs Justice Harris
Judgment delivered on 15 June 2026
For more information or advice on family law matters, readers are encouraged to contact the legal team at southgate solicitors at 02080040065 or hello@southgate.co.uk. It’s important to note that the content of this article is general information and not legal advice, and readers should seek independent expert advice for their specific situations. Our experienced team at southgate solicitors is here to provide expert guidance and support.
Send your details to us and we will call you back to take further information about your matter, or you can click the number below.
Send your details to us and we will call you back to take further information about your matter, or you can click the number below.